A-Infos (en) anarkismo.net - awsm.nz: Movie Review: 'Alone in Berlin' (2016) by LAMA (AWSM), Review of a movie about resistance in Nazi Germany. (ca, de, it, pt)[machine translation]

Nazi Germany continues to be a rich topic for filmmakers. There are many complex 
aspects to that regime and its history. This means it can be approached in many 
ways from comedy to serious drama. Alone in Berlin (2016) is an example of the 
latter. It fits within a subset of movies that address opposition to the Nazis. 
In this case, the source material is a 1947 book that covers the non-fiction 
activities of Otto and Elise Hampel. They were a working-class couple, here named 
Otto (Brendan Gleeson) and Anna Quangel (Emma Thompson). Some changes have been 
made in the fictionalising of the story. In the movie, the couple becomes engaged 
in their independent resistance work in reaction to news of the death of their 
son. He is killed at the very start of the film while serving as a soldier. The 
husband works as a foreman in a small industrial workshop. He takes it upon 
himself to initiate opposition via the writing of postcards with defiant slogans 
upon them, leaving them on the steps of public offices and other places. Soon the 
police are on their case. That's the plot.

The acting, cinematography, music and mise-en-scene uniformly work in the movie 
in a downbeat way. That is not a criticism. It wisely avoids putting a glossy 
patina on what was a horrible regime. It doesn't get the usual Hollywood 
treatment and that's a good thing. Gleeson in particular exudes a sorrowful 
demeanour that barely allows him a smile. There is a fire underneath but 
outwardly his character is just another worker drone in service of the system. 
Likewise Thompson is a million miles from any sort of charisma in her portrayal 
of an ordinary woman trying to deal with the death of a son at the hands of a 
state she can't believe in any more. The camera work is conventional and doesn't 
draw attention to itself. Likewise, the neighbourhood where the characters live 
is a drab brown. These parts of the film all tend to work in its favour.

Despite the positive parts of the film, there are things that could be said to 
work against it. One is the role and acting of Daniel Bruhl. He plays the Gestapo 
investigator Eschereich who is assigned the task of tracking down the mysterious 
card writer. Eschereich is an old-school, scientific detective who is interested 
in methodically figuring out who the culprit is. That might sound weird to 
mention, but in the Third Reich the internal politics were such that his 
superiors are more interested in framing the first person who comes along to suit 
a political need, rather than find the actual ‘wrong-doer'. Bruhl is a capable 
actor who is easy to like and the contrast between his character's motivations 
and his bosses, puts the viewer in an uneasy position of almost wanting him to 
succeed in his mission. That's no fault of Bruhl, he's doing his job, but his 
dynamism is worryingly seductive if you aren't careful. You might be kind and say 
this merely makes the film more subtle than your average portrayal of Hitler's 
Germany. The extent to which you see it that way will depend on your own 
impression of course.

Drama should have a sense of tension to it. That can take place within a 
character, between a character and others, or conflict between the character and 
his/her environment. A story such as Alone in Berlin would seem to be ready-made 
for building tension. In fact, though, there are very few such moments. Otto 
leaves the card on some steps and walks away. Somebody finds it and reads it. 
This is shown in such a perfunctory way that it elicits no jolt of concern for 
Otto. There is one point where Otto is almost discovered by a bystander who 
intercepts one of his cards. But there are no real heart-stopping moments where 
you take the side of the character on an emotional level and feel personal 
empathy with his escape. Director Perez would do well to study Hitchcock's oeuvre 
to see how you could build the dramatic tension lacking in this film.

So we are provided an interesting antagonist in the shape of Eschereich and 
little emotionally derived empathy for the people you should support. Since we 
are never introduced to the son, we don't feel emotionally invested in the 
character or his fate and by extension his parents. So all you are left with is 
the need to remind yourself periodically on an intellectual, rational level that 
the Nazis were bad and yes, the dowdy couple are very much worthy of the viewers' 
support. That's ok but probably doesn't lend enough depth. Which is a shame. 
Alone in Berlin may not be essential viewing, therefore, but any film that 
positively acknowledges opposition to Hitler has to be valued.

Related Link: https://awsm.nz/?p=8953

https://awsm.nz/?p=8953

https://www.anarkismo.net/article/32173
_________________________________________
A - I N F O S  N E W S  S E R V I C E
By, For, and About Anarchists
Send news reports to A-infos-en mailing list
A-infos-en@ainfos.ca
Subscribe/Unsubscribe http://ainfos.ca/mailman/listinfo/a-infos-en
Archive: http://ainfos.ca/en