A - I n f o s
a multi-lingual news service by, for, and about anarchists
News in all languages
Last 40 posts (Homepage)
archives of old posts
The last 100 posts, according
The First Few Lines of The Last 10 posts in:
First few lines of all posts of last 24 hours |
of past 30 days |
of 2002 |
of 2003 |
of 2004 |
of 2005 |
of 2006 |
of 2007 |
of 2008 |
of 2009 |
of 2010 |
of 2011 |
of 2012 |
of 2013 |
of 2014 |
of 2015 |
of 2016 |
of 2017 |
Syndication Of A-Infos - including
RDF - How to Syndicate A-Infos
Subscribe to the a-infos newsgroups
(en) US, black rose fed: CAMPUS FASCISM: TURNING POINT USA AND ITS LINKS TO THE FAR-RIGHT By Kristina Khan and Shane Burley, Truth Out
Sat, 10 Feb 2018 09:53:53 +0200
On November 22, 2017, Joel Valdez and Blair Nelson, two members of Turning Point USA
(TPUSA) and both students at the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign (UIUC), joined
Gavin McInnes on his program, "Get Off My Lawn." The young "conservatives" excitedly
promoted their appearance on his show earlier in the week. McInnes, who is founder of the
Proud Boys, has been thoroughly investigated by the Southern Poverty Law Center and
describes himself as a "Western Chauvinist." He has become a leader in the "civic
nationalist" contingent encircling the "alt-right." McInnis interviewed Valdez and Nelson
about their encounter with a fellow student on campus on November 16, asking Nelson, "Why
did you not punch him in the face?" ---- TPUSA, famous for its aggressive tactics against
leftist professors across US campuses, was founded in 2012 by a disgruntled Charlie Kirk,
who failed to get into the United States Military Academy at West Point. Kirk hardly built
TPUSA into the organization it is today, however; the nonprofit is funded largely by
Republican mega-donors and is a source of controversy for allegedly funding student
government campaigns on several campuses.
McInnes asked them about an alleged "wild attack by an antifa professor" who supposedly
confronted Nelson and Valdez "just for being conservatives." The instructor they were
referring to was Tariq Khan, a US Air Force veteran and graduate student at the
university. Khan challenged this characterization, saying he confronted the two after they
made what he felt was a veiled threat against his children. Khan, his wife (one of the
authors of this piece) and one of his children had been filmed by right-wing, anti-Muslim
student activists in the same spot on campus two years earlier, and UIUC's chapter of
TPUSA had already attempted to push two campaigns against two different women of color
associated with UIUC this past fall: an undergraduate student and a staff member. After
the confrontation between Valdez and Khan, TPUSA members and allies created a campaign of
threats and intimidation across media platforms.
According to TPUSA's website, they have chapters at around 350 college campuses and
approximately 64 chapters in high schools around the country. TPUSA is the home of the
"Professor Watchlist," a McCarthy-style blacklist of "biased" professors. On Comedy
Central's show, "The Opposition," Kirk described the "Professor Watchlist" as "an
awareness tool," but if a professor makes the list, they then "coincidentally" become the
target of malicious campaigns.
Amanda Gailey, an English professor at the University of Nebraska (UN), is one of now
hundreds of professors across the country who were targeted by the group, receiving
threats in her inbox after they launched a campaign against her and UN graduate student
Courtney Lawton. These campaigns nearly all roll out the same way: TPUSA self publishes a
story on their site, Campus Reform, of alleged "abuse" or bias from the left; the victim
of the story starts getting threats; and universities find themselves dealing with outside
pressure to get rid of the professor or student in question. Kirk said to CNN in December
2017 about his "Professor Watchlist,"
We do not call for any of that sort of harassment. We don't condone it. We don't try to
facilitate any sort of cyber bullying or harassment. And just because you put up the
words, or another article that's been written about a professor in an aggregated format,
does not mean we should be held responsible for what other people do.
But it's not just anonymous virtual trolls that are intimidating professors. TPUSA's
tactics are shady, to say the least. Across the country, TPUSA members film leftists
without their consent, both on and off campus. They have tried to infiltrate leftist
meetings and spaces. They stalk leftists online, documenting their lives and doxxing them.
Intimidation and infiltration strategies like these border on being illegal, and TPUSA
knows it. Their members walk a carefully directed line to avoid negative publicity, and
should any arise, they do massive amounts of damage control through their own media outlets.
The New Yorker published its own exposé on TPUSA, citing anti-Blackness and illegal
election funding, which shed a bit more light on the practices of this nonprofit. But
what's yet to be thoroughly investigated but beginning to be uncovered in central Illinois
and Nebraska are TPUSA's connections to neo-fascist organizations and individuals.
Despite Valdez' claims on "Get Off My Lawn" of being present for the anti-Trump rally
because of an "interest in civil discourse," TPUSA members harassed and filmed many of
that day's attendees and speakers, including Khan. One member, Andrew Minik, then posted
the video they took on the Campus Reform site, along with the erroneous story about Khan.
Andrew Minik is one of many TPUSA members paid to write for Campus Reform, which is a
joint project of the National Leadership Institute. The Institute provides an online forum
for students to "report liberal abuse" and to even "get paid to hold their school
Joel Valdez, Blair Nelson and Andrew Minik aren't doing anything other TPUSA members
haven't done. Lying about their interactions with their fellow students and their
professors on campus is how TPUSA operates as an organization. Administrators at UIUC
"knew it would be trouble," when they became aware that there would be a TPUSA chapter on
campus. But what makes the UIUC chapter seem unique is their happy interaction with the
From Trolling to Threats
The culture of "exposure" that TPUSA intends to bring to college campuses is patterned
after identifying specific people, often students or adjunct faculty, and then spurring
them on with erroneous claims that leave them personally and professionally vulnerable.
After Minik published his erroneous article about Khan on Campus Reform, the death threats
started pouring in. Threats from Neo-Nazis, white nationalists and Islamophobes came from
all over the country to Khan's inbox. Khan, who is partially of Pakistani descent,
appeared to be singled out in part because of his ethnicity, leaning to their heavy focus
on Muslim immigration. His academic department and the Graduate Employees Union office
received threats and phone calls demanding Khan be expelled. As the story exploded, it was
picked up by sites like InfoWars and shared by Ben Shapiro, Lou Dobbs, Charlie Kirk and
former White House Communications Director Anthony Scaramucci.
While Khan's department refused to cave to the threats, university administrators in the
Office of Conflict Resolution are punishing Khan for pushing back against Valdez's threat.
Khan was called in and an administrator assigned to the complaint filed by Valdez asked
why Khan "didn't just walk away."
"We've been reporting the actions of these white supremacists to the administration for
the last three years and they have done absolutely nothing to protect students, staff and
faculty of color from white-supremacist threats," said Khan. "So when a fascist made a
veiled threat against my children, I had no choice but to confront them myself, because
the administration won't confront them."
Khan was not allowed to read his entire defense statement in a meeting with administration
and was told that if he appealed the university's decision, he would have to pay more
money for the punishment process - a threat of sorts to a graduate student father of three
making poverty wages.
Unfortunately, Khan's situation of not finding support from his university is becoming
terrifyingly common. On December 28, George Ciccariello-Maher announced his resignation
from his tenured position at Drexel University. "After nearly a year of harassment by
right-wing, white supremacist media outlets and internet mobs, after death threats and
threats of violence directed against me and my family, my situation has become
unsustainable," said Ciccariello-Maher in a public statement. Academics like Mark Bray,
Mike Isaacson and others have become targets of an increasingly hostile set of far-right
student and media organizations, targeting them for casual statements or left-wing views
in their private lives. While conservative organizations have always made an effort to
confront what they see as left-wing bias on college campuses, the tenor of that activism
has changed since Donald Trump and the trolls of the "alt-right" came on the scene,
creating a cloud of potential violence and serious career implications.
Sitting under Minik's Campus Reform article about Khan, comments such as "Chuck Neely's"
were reported by Khan's department to police. "Expelled? No. We need to deal with this as
white men in a white nation," wrote "Neely."
"This garbage dares to assault us? We physically remove him from this plane of existence.
He has zero right to exist in our nation, he is made to leave one way or another." Other
TPUSA members joined in the threats, promising to pay the legal fees for any attacker.
Like his fellow TPUSA members, Valdez claims to simply be a "conservative" who believes in
capitalism and the free market, yet he proudly shares on social media accounts the now
infamous "alt-right" symbol Pepe the Frog, work by rape-apologist Mike Cernovich, and
graciously thanks extremist "Infowars" conspiracy peddler Alex Jones for any retweets.
Nelson has argued genocide is merely a leftist construct, an opinion that he disagrees with.
These patterns of racism make their way to the top of Turning Point's leadership. As The
New Yorker reported, Crystal Clayton, one of TPUSA's most prominent members for five
years, said, "I hate Black people. Like fuck them all.... I hate Blacks. End of story."
TPUSA also posted and then hastily removed a blatantly anti-Semitic tweet last November.
UIUC released a statement in the fall restating their commitment to "defending free
speech" on campus. Despite extremely racist chalking, white supremacist
"It's-okay-to-be-white" fliers, ongoing stalking incidents, harassment and filming of
students of color by "conservative" students, and even physically violent incidents
against people of color, it would seem that for now, the University of Illinois is
choosing to uphold white supremacist values on campus. As the Traditionalist Worker Party
and Vanguard America prepare to launch propaganda campaigns aimed at Midwestern
universities this spring, some student activists of color at UIUC aren't hopeful their
campus will protect them.
More Than Conservative
While much of Turning Point's public media argues that its members have no association
with the white nationalists of the "alt-right" or the street violence of the Proud Boys,
their short track-record has proven that rhetoric to be a mirage. Kirk's relationship to
the University of Illinois might help provide insight on how TPUSA doesn't just condone
this behavior, but was in fact founded on it.
In 2015, UIUC made national headlines over a newly established "white student union" on
campus. White supremacists created it on Facebook directly after Black student activists
held a rally on campus the same day. The page, reported by many people to police, asked
for identification of Black activists who, the page's owners claimed, were "terrorizing"
the campus. The page also posted videos by Jared Taylor, founder of the white nationalist
American Renaissance, and told people to "check out" Richard Spencer's own National Policy
Institute. With a lack of active support by the university to its students of color,
students and community members met with campus police to try to educate them about these
groups, yet the administration and the police failed to follow up on those concerns.
Other white student union pages started popping up around the country in response to the
national attention, and it was rumored that most weren't run by actual students. UIUC's
Illinois "White Student Union" page, however, was run by a group of UIUC students. In
anonymously submitted screenshots of text messages, former Traditionalist Worker Party
member Michelle Kapelski told Debbie Bernal, the current president of UIUC's Turning Point
chapter, that she helped start the page "as a joke."
One of the first people who interacted with the page positively (liking and sharing its
posts) was a student by the name of Artur Sak. Sak, a young man whose parents emigrated
from Poland, has since graduated, but served on the first-ever national student board of
TPUSA while at UIUC. When the story about the white student union blew up in the national
news, Sak stopped interacting with the page entirely. As of last fall, both Sak and the
page are gone from UIUC's campus, yet Turning Point remains. In Sak's bio for TPUSA he
says he was with the organization from the beginning, an association that seems to echo
TPUSA's current membership.
While the extent to which TPUSA works with self-identified white nationalists and
neo-fascists is not wholly clear, it is obvious that their conservative branding centered
on "free-speech and free-markets" is misleading. Their roots are planted in racist
ideologies and handed to enthusiastic young people unrestrained by a fear of consequences.
At UIUC's campus, for example, rather than seeing TPUSA members holding "civil
discussions" on fiscal conservatism, one is more likely to see TPUSA members on the quad
trying to convince passersby to sign a petition calling on the administration to reinstate
"Chief Illiniwek," a racist sports mascot that the National Collegiate Athletic
Association forced UIUC to retire years ago.
Kaitlyn Mullen, a TPUSA campus coordinator at the University of Nebraska, was only one of
three dissenting voices against a resolution by the City of Lincoln committing to standing
up against hate speech in the wake of Charlottesville's nightmare. The other two
dissenting voices came from members of Patriot Front - otherwise known as "Blood and Soil"
- one of whom had himself marched in Charlottesville the day Heather Heyer was murdered.
All three voiced feeling victimized along with having a love of free markets. The city's
resolution against hate speech passed 5-0.
The "alt-right" targets universities because most are unable or unwilling to prohibit
white nationalist and white supremacist ideas without serious legal battles. "Free speech"
becomes the sound bite of university administrations and fascists alike in defending the
presence of Turning Point USA, Richard Spencer and others like them. It has become so
common for racist and fascist groups to plot on campuses that the Southern Poverty Law
Center released a student resource guide for dealing with the "alt-right." But as Khan's
case shows, these debates are hardly debates and they are hardly contained on university
This article was originally published with Truth Out as "Young Fascists on Campus: Turning
Point USA and Its Far-Right Connections."
Shane Burley is a writer and filmmaker based in Portland, Oregon. He is the author of
Fascism Today: What It Is and How to End It (AK Press) and articles with numerous left
publication. Follow him on Twitter: @shane_burley1.
Kristina Khan is a mother, reproductive justice educator, board member of the Channing
Murray Foundation and organizer with Build Programs Not Jails in Champaign-Urbana, Illinois.
To read more about Turning Point USA's harassment campaign against our member, Tariq Khan
at the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign (UIUC), we recommend reading "Campus
Anti-Fascist Network Statement in Support of Tariq Khan."
A - I N F O S N E W S S E R V I C E
By, For, and About Anarchists
Send news reports to A-infos-en mailing list
A-Infos Information Center