A - I n f o s
a multi-lingual news service by, for, and about anarchists **

News in all languages
Last 40 posts (Homepage) Last two weeks' posts

The last 100 posts, according to language
Castellano_ Deutsch_ Nederlands_ English_ Français_ Italiano_ Polski_ Português_ Russkyi_ Suomi_ Svenska_ Trk�_ The.Supplement

The First Few Lines of The Last 10 posts in:
Castellano_ Deutsch_ Nederlands_ English_ Français_ Italiano_ Polski_ Português_ Russkyi_ Suomi_ Svenska_ Trk�
First few lines of all posts of last 24 hours || of past 30 days | of 2002 | of 2003 | of 2004 | of 2005 | of 2006 | of 2007 | of 2008

Syndication Of A-Infos - including RDF | How to Syndicate A-Infos
Subscribe to the a-infos newsgroups
{Info on A-Infos}

(en) Italy: FdCA Council of Delegates Statement - Secularism, a means of education for coexistence [it]

Date Tue, 05 Feb 2008 15:41:06 +0200

In the most economically advanced countries today, while the State is becoming
increasingly "lighter" in economic terms and reducing the supply of social
services - in order also to adapt the cost of social services to the market
standard consistent with production (as in the case of the low social spending
of emerging economies) - it is becoming increasingly concerned with matters of
ethics and bioethics, with a plethora of laws on these areas (abortion, IVF
treatment, stem cell research, euthanasia, infibulation, etc.) and in personal
areas, such as domestic partnerships, divorce, separation, etc.). ---- In this
difficult period for capitalist accumulation, characterized by a mature
capitalist structure and by the entry onto the market of aggressive new
producers, the State is developing one of its classic functions, that of
policeman, and is contributing to the control of the labour market and the
mechanisms of social production that are necessary to the creation of profit.

As it is unable to depress the role of the tertiary sector involved in the
provision of services over a certain limit - a sector which also produces
profit for capital - it is laying down regulations to manage personal matters
and govern the changing social composition of the workforce.

The nature of the workforce at the end of the last century and the structure of
wages had created a demographic balance which in the West was characterized by
a low birth rate, so as to maintain standards of living that were compatible
with the available income, the standard of which was relatively high. Part of
these measures on the social level were a demographic policy that used income,
abortion and contraception as instruments of demographic planning. What upset
this situation, necessitating further intervention was the explosion of the
women's movement, which provoked profound changes not only to their individual
social role, but also to the collective role of men and women. This led to
changes with regard to the family, such as divorce and civil unions, which is
simply the creation of a new type of legal relationship to enable the law and
the State to intervene in relationships that would otherwise go unnoticed.

The tendency to juridicize personal relationships be they homosexual or
heterosexual recognizes and regulates this change at the same time, using means
which are typical of illuminated reformism.

The relentless waves of migration, a result of the capital's strategic
decisions on the management of the labour market, but also of wider economic
and social phenomena, have widened and changed the spectrum of problems and
thus the policing function of the State in the so-called mature capitalist
countries has grown through the adoption of an adequate instrumental apparatus
of laws.

And where the State was and is unable to produce these laws, capital itself has
done so through the market.

Jurists (legal experts) - even the most traditional - are among the first to
admit these days that it is the market and the professional corporations
(doctors, biologists, pharmaceutical companies, etc.) who produce laws and
enforce them much more efficiently than the State, without the use of any
Parliament. It is a phenomenon often known as the Lex Mercatoria, or Law

We thus see the strengthening of:

* juridical pluralism: the co-existence of several juridical orders (for
example, the law of the State, of the mafia, of the market and of religions,
which operate over the same territory;

* regulatory pluralism: the contemporary enforcement - independently from
national or State borders - of regulations enacted by various sources which
regulate the same phenomenon (local or regional authorities, States, the EU,
international bodies, but also Churches, cultural or ethnic communities, etc.);

* ethical pluralism: the search for legal bases (essential elements) which can
be shared by all, and act as a common denominator, beyond which lies the
relativism of values. In order words, everyone has his or her own values and
can cultivate and exercise them.

>From this we can see that no one Truth exists, but many truths that coexist;
that no one Law exists, but many laws; that no one Company exists, but many
companies producing and thriving; that no one Individual exists, but many

It is a victory for relativism in law, in morals, in economics, in social life
and in relationships. The sort of relativism that allows us, for example, to
consider equally both monogamous and polygamous couples, heterosexual and
same-sex couples. In a situation such as the one described, the secularity of
the institutions and of people is an essential element for the management of
the current phase (as the development of productive forces and of the
contingent economic dynamics).

And here, every political force, every party, and even every religious
confession, provides its own version of secularism, in general using an
adjective to define and complete it. Secularism therefore become just, true,
positive, relative, etc., according to the case.

Looking for a moment at the vision of secularism held by religious confessions
(that we anarchist communists identify as a group of people who believe
themselves to be and know they are and who therefore form international
agencies, or businesses selling sacredness) and in particular the [Roman]
Catholic confession, it is important to remember that for the popes and above
all the pop currently reigning, secularism in the Catholic vision is just and
positive, as it is born from Catholic culture (see the numerous Vatican
documents on the matter).

For Catholics, secularism comes from the rejection of relativism, as the
reigning pontiff often reminds us. There is only one truth, the truth revealed
by God, interpreted by the Catholic hierarchy. The relationship with the State
and the institutions becomes a matter of adopting Catholic values, tempered by
measured tolerance towards the positions of others, towards which there
nonetheless exists a moral sense of superiority on the part of believers (the
superiority of Western, Christian and in particular Catholic values).

Laws must be inspired by Catholic values and need be obeyed only if they
correspond to religious commandments. Hence the no to divorce and to different
forms of legalized civil unions, no to abortion, to contraception, to genetic
intervention on embryos, to any sexuality not aimed at procreation, and to
euthanasia of any form.

And in order to promote all this: yes to Catholic schools, yes to a
Catholic-inspired curriculum at state schools and to religious instruction as
part of the curriculum, yes to the financing of Catholic aid programmes and
charities, yes to economic aid to Church structures and tax benefits.

This strategy has led to the attack on Law 194/78 [1] which, it must be said,
has reduced by 60% the use of abortion by Italian citizens, though much remains
to be done in the case of immigrant women. Compared to the laws currently in
force in a great many other countries, this law has been far more effective in
reducing the requests for abortion, and would certainly be even more effective
if it were not for the incessant work of deterrence by the Catholic church to
the use of contraception and contraceptive methods to encourage responsible

The attack on the law - objectively aimed at the rights of women, whose bodies
are considered as the holders of a social function, a sort of family and social
household appliance - reveals the serious lack of human respect for women and
the misogyny of the ecclesiastic hierarchy and the body of the Catholic
Church, its profoundly unhealthy vision of love and good, aimed at a fantastic
conception of man, the idea of God.

Feelings made up of closeness, physicality, sexuality and solidity between two
people is replaced with the alienated love for an abstract God, the product of
the anguish of human beings.

But the attack on Law 194/78 has its roots in fortuitous political needs,
dictated by the need for a strategy aimed at building a fundamentalist,
neo-conservative political and social bloc which can hold together a political
alliance whose objective is to re-establish social and productive, not to
mention political, relations of an authoritarian nature, which in turn can
provide greater support for capitalist accumulation.

And it is these designs, above all, that we must unmask and combat by accepting
the principle of secularism without adjectives as a means of education for

In the anarchist communist concept, the society that we want to build is
dynamic, in continual evolution and change, a society that accepts diversity as
a value, a society that - unlike the Marxist variety - has no truth that it
wants to impose, not even atheism, a society that aims to achieve complete
happiness on earth, through equality, including gender equality, and an end to
exploitation of one man by another and freedom from wage slavery.

Council of Delegates

Pesaro, 27th January 2008

Translator's note:
1. The law on abortion.


From: Federazione dei Comunisti Anarchici <internazionale@fdca.it>
A - I N F O S N E W S S E R V I C E
By, For, and About Anarchists
A-infos-en mailing list

A-Infos Information Center