A - I n f o s
a multi-lingual news service by, for, and about anarchists **

News in all languages
Last 40 posts (Homepage) Last two weeks' posts

The last 100 posts, according to language
Castellano_ Deutsch_ Nederlands_ English_ Français_ Italiano_ Polski_ Português_ Russkyi_ Suomi_ Svenska_ Türkçe_ The.Supplement
First few lines of all posts of last 24 hours || of past 30 days | of 2002 | of 2003 | of 2004 | of 2005 | of 2006

Syndication Of A-Infos - including RDF | How to Syndicate A-Infos
Subscribe to the a-infos newsgroups
{Info on A-Infos}

(en) Britain, Class War, British anarchism and the Miners' Strike Capital & Class, Autumn 2005 by Benjamin Franks - II. (2/2)

Date Wed, 25 Jan 2006 10:14:28 +0200


Conclusion
Since the miners' strike, liberal anarchism has declined, while class
struggle anarchism with a commitment to anticapitalism has,
concomitantly, risen. This can be seen not only in the provocative
targets of the anarchist sections of the alternative globalisation
movements, but also in the extent to which Freedom has altered
both in terms of its editorial board and its content. The newspaper is
now more consistent with class struggle (or social)
anarchism-despite the continued involvement of Rooum and his
Wildcat cartoon.28 The reengagement of anarchism with industrial
struggles has had a marked influence on the interests and forms of
political activity of British anarchist groups. Libertarians gained
greater confidence to search out routes of solidarity. The eventual
defeat of the miners also put in place a reconsideration of agency and
organisation within libertarian movements, which has had a
noticeable impact on the tactics and structures employed and
endorsed by consistent libertarians. Although liberal anarchism has
largely declined, this is partly due to the recognition by those
formerly categorised as such that contesting capitalist social relations
is a dominant factor in their forms of resistance. Similarly, class
struggle libertarians have become aware of the class nature of many
of the forms of action formerly dismissed as 'liberal'.

Notes

1. The British Library (Kings Cross), the British Newspaper Library
(Colindale), and the National Library of Scotland (Edinburgh).

2. I would like to acknowledge and thank Trevor Bark, Ian Bone,
Lesley Stevenson, Mark Ward and Rowan Wilson for their
assistance in the writing of this paper, either in providing data, in
correcting some of my grammatical solecisms, or in indicating areas
for greater structural cohesion.

3. For an ethical critique of this form of liberal contractmaking, see
G. A. Cohen (2002).

4. See, for instance,Tucker's arguments on the beneficence of free
markets in 'Capital profits and interest'. For a wider discussion, see
Brooks (1996: 76, 79-82).

5. Brooks describes Tucker's newspaper Liberty as 'probably the
most significant individualist anarchist journal in the world' (Brooks,
1996: 75).

6. Bookchin, for instance, identifies direct democratic
decision-making with social anarchism, while he equates consensus
and/or the rejection of organisational structures with egoism
(Bookchin, 1995: 17, 60). However, many tactics consistent with
social anarchism do not utilise such formalised organisation. Bob
Black (1997) has written a lengthy, and occasionally contradictory,
polemical study that draws out some of the inconsistencies in
Bookchin's approach. see also Brown (2004).

7. See the International Workers Association, online at

8. For the sake of convenience, I will be including autonomous
Marxism and libertarian communism under the title 'anarchist'. See,
too, Cleaver (1994). In an act of self-promotion-and for a fuller
discussion of the main characteristics of class struggle anarchism,
see Franks (2005).

9. The centrality of Marxist analysis to anarchism has also been
recognised by others including Sean Sheehan (2003: 57-72) and
Stuart Christie and Albert Meltzer (1984).

10. For examples of the importance of prefiguration, the means
reflecting the ends, see the quote by Guillaume in Kenafick (1984:
7); Avrich (1987: 7-8, 29); and Organise! (1992) no. 26, April-June,
p. 20.

11. Some, like Black Flag, cast doubts on Freedom's claim, pointing
to the hiatus in production of more than a decade, from 1933-44,
and the change in editorial policy away from anarchist communism
(Black Flag supplement no. 3, [undated 1986R] p. 2).

12. Note, too, that Freedom's definition of anarchism (January 1983:
1) makes no explicit reference to opposition to capitalism or
advocacy of class struggle. This is in contrast to anarcho-syndicalists
such as Christie and Meltzer (1984: 21) and DAM (19843: 9).

13. 'The Miners' Strike Twenty Years On: Challenges and Changes'
conference, Northumbria University, 11-13 July 2004.

14. The Miner, 7 February 1985, p. 4.

15. 'Pit War', The Sun, 13 March 1984, p. 1.

16. See, for instance, the profile of Paul Shane, who played Ted
Bovis in a popular TV 'comedy' Hi-de-Hi!, who was quoted as
saying he wanted a strike ballot, The Sun, 1 April 1984, p. 8.

17. Accusations of insufficient support for the miners appear to be
employed as a way of dismissing opponents, since the same author
accuses Class War (a rival class-struggle grouping) of the same
thing. The group's publication, Class War, although lax at the start
of the strike, perhaps due to a long run-in time before publication,
later dedicated around half of each issue to the miners' struggle, so
this allegation against them seems illjudged.

18. No relation to the British libertarian Marxists who also use this
name.

19. See Class War, 'Victory to the Hit Squads' edition, undated, p. 4:

Have you ever noticed how in Leftie papers they only ever print
pictures of miners being beaten up by the police. They never use
pictures which would cheer us up of the police being given a good
kicking ... They always portray us as passive victims of police
violence ... Just occasionally they will say that people fought back
against the coppers-but this is only when they've been attacked first
and had to use self-defence.

By contrast, the editors of Freedom saw little to celebrate in the
actions of the miners. They rejected a query asking for images of
successful resistance: 'Images of us winning? Do you want us to
bury our heads in the sand?' The editors, Letters Page (1985)
Freedom, vol. 45, no. 5, p. 3, May.

20. The Miners' Strike (2004) BBC2 television programme, 27
January.

21. For instance, the Anarchist Communist Federation, and
especially the British group Wildcat: see Wildcat, 1992.

22. See, for instance, The Miner, October 1983, p. 7; see, too, the
NUM (1984) 'fact sheet'. In the last two decades, the NUM had
given and received support from other unions during industrial
disputes (Taylor, 1984: 273, 282, 310).

23. For a wider discussion of this from an autonomist Marxist
perspective, see Bowring, 2004; Cleaver, 1979; Hardt & Negri, 2001;
Witheford, 1994.

24. The Wintertons suggest that the number of
independently-produced strike bulletins was surprisingly small, and
this might have had an adverse effect on maintaining solidarity
(Winterton & Winterton, 1989: 142).

25. See, for instance, Coulter, Miller & Walker (1984) for a detailed
account of state oppression, and Sutcliffe & Hill (1985) for
information on the assault on the economic welfare of miners and
their families.

26. The Miner, special issue (1984) 16 April, p. 2.

27. See, for instance, the RTS report on the link-up with the
Underground workers and the Liverpool dock strike, online at ,
accessed 2 July 2004.

28. A discussion about Freedom, which included some of its current
editors, on the Urbany5 online bulletin board, largely confirms this
turn; see 'The future of Freedom, fortnightly anarchist newspaper' at
, accessed July 4, 2004.

References

Adeney, M. & J. Lloyd (1986) Miners' Strike, 1984-85: Loss
Without Limit (Routledge) London.

Albon, A. (1996) 'The pieces of silver', reprinted in Booth, Into the
1990s with Green Anarchist (Green Anarchist Books) Oxford.

Andrew, J. (1985) 'What are they frightened of?' in Freedom, vol.
46, no. 1, January, p. 7.

Atton, C. (1999) 'Green Anarchist: A case study of collective action
in the radical media', in Anarchist Studies, vol. 3, no. 7, March.

Aufheben (1998) 'The politics of anti-road struggle and the struggle
of anti-road politics: The case of the No M11 Link Road campaign',
available online at .

Avrich, P. (1987) Bakunin & Nechaev (Freedom) London.

Baird, C., M. Baird, J. Calwell, B. Raeside & J. Raeside (1994)
'Anarchism in Scotland: Part 1', in Scottish Anarchist, no. 1, pp.
20-22; also available online at .

Bakunin, M. (1984) Marxism, Freedom and the State, trans.
Kenafick (Freedom) London.

Black, B. (1997) Anarchy After Leftism (Columbia Alternative
Library) Columbia, USA.

Bloomfield, B. (1986) 'Women's support groups at Maerdy', in R.
Samuel, B. Bloomfield & G. Boanas (eds.) The Enemy Within: Pit
Villages and the Miners' Strike of 1984-5 (Routledge and Kegan
Paul) London, pp. 154-165.

Bookchin, M. (1995) Social Anarchism or Lifestyle Anarchism: An
Unbridgeable Chasm (AK Press) Edinburgh.

Booth, S. (1996) Into the 1990$ with Green Anarchist (Green
Anarchist Books) Oxford.

Bowring, F. (2004) 'From the mass worker to the multitude: A
theoretical contextualisation of Hardt and Negri's Empire', in Capital
& Class, no. 83, Summer, pp. 101-132.

Braidotti, R. (1993) 'Discontinuous becomings: Deleuze on the
becoming-woman of philosophy', in Journal of the British Society of
Phenomenology, vol. 24, no. 1, January.

Broom, J. (1985) 'Dear Freedom', vol. 46, no. 4, April, p. 3.

Brooks, F. (1996) 'American individualist anarchism: What it was
and why it failed', in Journal of Political Ideologies, vol. 1, no. 1.

Brogden, M. (1986) 'Interviews at Armthorpe, December 1984', in
R. Samuel, B. Bloomfield & G. Boanas (eds.) The Enemy Within:
Pit Villages and the Miners' Strike of 1984-5 (Routledge and Kegan
Paul) London, pp. 166-202.

Brown, A. (1984) 'Trusting the miners', in Freedom, vol. 45, no. 9,
September, p. 3.

Brown, L. S. (2003) The Politics of Individualism: Liberalism,
Liberal Feminism and Anarchism (Black Rose) London.

_____ (2004) 'Looking back and moving forward: The radical
humanism of The Politics of Individualism', in Anarchist Studies,
vol. 12, no. 1.

Callinicos, A. & M. Simmons (1985) The Great Strike:The Miner's
Strike 1984-5 and its Lessons (Socialist Worker) London.

Campbell (1984) 'Anarcho-syndicalist objections', letter in Green
Anarchist, no. 3, November-December, p. 18.

Christie, S. (1980) The Christie File (Cienfuegos Press) Sanday,
Orkney.

Christie, S. & A. Meltzer (1984) The Floodgates of Anarchy (Kahn
& Averill) London.

Class War (1984123) 'We have our own ideas of time and "motion',
in Class War (undated, unnumbered) pp. 1-4.

_____ (1984eb) 'Victory to the hit squads', in Class War (undated,
unnumbered) pp. 1-6.

_____ (1984ec) 'Another fucking royal parasite', in Class War
(undated, unnumbered) pp. 1-6.

_____ (1985ea) 'We are Class War' in Class War ' You rich fucking
scumbag... we're gonna get you' edition (undated, unnumbered) pp.
1-6.

_____ (1985eb) 'The best cut of all', in Class War (undated,
unnumbered) pp. 1-8.

_____ (1991) This is Class War: An introduction to the Class War
Federation (AK Press) Stirling.

_____ (1997) 'Class War R.I.P.', available online at , March
[accessed April 7, 2005].

Cleaver, H. (1979) Reading 'Capital' Politically (Harvester Press)
Brighton.

_____ (1994) 'Kropotkin, self-valorization and the crisis of
Marxism', available online at , and also in Anarchist Studies, vol. 2,
no. 2, Autumn.

Cohen, G. (2002) 'The structure of proletarian unfreedom', in R.
Goodin & P. Pettit, Contemporary Political Philosophy: An
Anthology (Blackwell) Oxford.

Coulter, J., S. Miller & M. Walker (1984) State of Siege: Politics and
Policing of the Coalfields: Miners' Strike 1984 (Canary Press)
London.

Crass, G. Our struggle', in Peace News, no. 2226, 10 August, p. 13.

Curtis (1984) 'Miners', in Peace News, no. 2221, 25 May, pp. 10-12.

Dalla Costa, M. & S. James (1975) The Power of Women and the
Subversion of the Community (FallingWall) Bristol.

Dangerfield (1997) The Strange Death of Liberal England (Serif)
London.

Denis the Menace (1984) letter in Freedom, vol. 45, no. 8, August,
p. 3.

Direct Action Movement (19843) Strike Action (Dark Star & South
and East London DAM-IWA) London.

_____(1984ea) 'Miners' strike' in Direct Action, no. 17, undated, pp.
1-2.

_____ (1984b) 'Whose strike?' in Direct Action, no. 19, October, p.
1.

_____ (1984c) 'TUC-Can they deliver?' in Direct Action, no. 19,
October, p. 4.

_____ (1985) 'Still time to win' in Direct Action, no. 22, February, p.
1.

Do or Die (2003) 'Down with Empire! Up with Spring!' in Do or Die,
no. 10, pp. 1-101.

Douglass, D. (1985) Tell Us Lies About the Miners (Doncaster
DAM-IWA, Cambridge DAM-IWA & South London DAM-IWA)
Doncaster, Cambridge and London.

_____ (1986) Come and Wet This Truncheon: The Role of the
Police in the Coal Strike of 1984/1985 (South London DAM-IWA
Groups and Canary Press) Doncaster and Cambridge.

_____ (1991) Refracted Perspective: The Left, Working Class Trade
Unionism and the Miners (121 Bookshop) London.

_____ (1992) Coal Communities in Conflict: Heavy Stuff special
edition (Class War) London.

_____ (1999) All Power to the Imagination (Class War) London.

Fettes, C. (1984) 'What's radical', in Peace News, no. 2231, 19
October, p. 20.

Fishman, W. (1975) East End Jewish Radicals 1874-1914
(Duckworth) London.

Franks, B. (2003) 'The direct action ethic', in Anarchist Studies, vol.
11, no. 1, pp. 13-41.

_____ (2005?) Rebel Alliances: The Means and Ends of
Contemporary British Anarchisms (Dark Star & AK Press) London
and Edinburgh-forthcoming.

Freedom Editorial Collective (1984) 'Mine Kampf', in Freedom, vol.
45, no. 5, May, p. 1.

_____ (1985) 'The debate section: Spelling out the rules of the
game', in Freedom, vol. 46, no. 3, March, p. 12.

Gray, A. (1974) Leaving the Twentieth Century: The Incomplete
Work of the Situationist International (Free Fall) Brussels, Belgium.

Green Anarchist (19843) 'Enough is enough', in Green Anarchist,
no. 2, September-August [sic.], p. 2.

_____ (1984b) 'Terrorism-Government', in Green Anarchist, no. 3,
November-December, p. 2.

_____ (1984c) 'London Stop the City', in Green Anarchist, no. 3,
November-December, p. 4.

_____ (1984d) 'Birmingham STC', in Green Anarchist, no. 3,
November-December, p. 5.

_____ (1985) 'The State's brute violence', in 'News Extra' insert in
Green Anarchist, no. 6, May-June, pp. 1-2; reprinted in Green
Anarchist (1985) no. 7, July-August, pp. 3-4.

Hagger, N. (1984) Scargill the Stalinist? The Communist Role in the
1984 Miners' Strike-A Warning to the British People (Oak-Tree
Books) London.

Hardt, M. & T. Negri (2001) Empire (Harvard University Press)
London.

Hashman (1984) 'Switch on at six ...', in Peace News, no. 2227, 24
August, p. 17.

Holloway, J. (2002) Change the WorldWithout Taking Power
(Pluto) London.

Hull DAM/IWA (1984) 'Hull', in Freedom, vol. 45, no. 8, August, p.
7.

Hume, B. (1986) 'Hatfield main welfare organisation', in R. Samuel,
B. Bloomfield & G. Boanas (eds.) The Enemy Within: Pit Villages
and the Miners' Strike of 1984-5 (Routledge and Kegan Paul)
London, pp. 128-38.

Hunt, R. (1984) 'Where we stand', in Green Anarchist, no. 2,
September-August [sic.], pp. 8-9.

Ingarfield, G. (1984) 'Feedback', in Freedom, vol. 45, no. 8, August,
p. 5.

International Workers Association, online at [accessed 10 August
2004].

Johnson, C. (1984) 'General strike', in Freedom, September, vol. 45,
no .9, p. 1.

Kenafick, K. (1984) 'Foreword' to M. Bakunin, Marxism, Freedom
and the State (Freedom) London.

Kendall, W. (1969) The Revolutionary Movement in Britain
1900-21:The Origins of British Communism (Wiedenfield &
Nicolson) London.

Kropotkin, P. (1997e) [1908] 'Syndicalism and anarchism" in Black
Flag, no. 210, pp. 24-7.

Knight, I. (1986) 'Upton, the Infants' Support Group', in R. Samuel,
B. Bloomfield & G. Boanas (eds.) The Enemy Within: Pit Villages
and the Miners' Strike of 1984-5 (Routledge and Kegan Paul)
London, pp. 122-7.

Lenin, V. (1975) 'Left-Wing' Communism: An Infantile Disorder
(Foreign Languages Press) Beijing.

Lowe, M. (1984) '... Are we mad', letter in Peace News, no. 2227, 24
August, p. 17.

MacGregor, I. (1986) with R. Tyler, The Enemies Within: Story of
the Miners' Strike (HarperCollins) London.

Marx, K. (1992) 'Provisional rules', in D. Fernbach (ed.) The First
International and After: Political Writings, vol. 3 (Penguin)
Harmondsworth.

Martin, J. 'Performing politics: Class, ideology and discourse in
Marx's Eighteenth Brumaire', online at [accessed 11 August 2004];
(page references refer to standard print-out) pp. 1-13.

May, T. (1994) The Political Philosophy of Post-Structural
Anarchism (Pennsylvania State University Press) Pennsylvania,
USA. Meltzer

, A. (1996) I Couldn't Paint Golden Angels (AK Press & Kate
Sharpley Library) Edinburgh and London.

Member of Class War newspaper collective (1985) 'Class War', in
Green Anarchist, no. 4, January-February, pp. 6-7.

Milne, S. (2004) 'A different kind of Britain', in The Guardian, 6
March, p. 21.

NUM (1984) Fact Sheet (National Union of Miners) Barnsley.

Patton, R. (1986) 'Letters', in R. Samuel, B. Bloomfield & G.
Boanas (eds.) The Enemy Within: Pit Villages and the Miners'
Strike of 1984-5 (Routledge and Kegan Paul) London, pp. 216-7.

Peace News (1984) 'Agenda', in Peace News, no. 2224, 13 July, p.
18.

Platt, S. (1984) 'Dig deep for the miners', in Peace News, no. 2227,
24 August, pp. 10-11.

PNR (1985) 'Bedford Anarchists', in Freedom, vol. 46, no. 2,
February, p. 5.

PNR (1985e) 'Bedford', in Class War The best cut of all' edition
(undated, unnumbered) p. 7.

Quail, J. (1978) The Slow Burning Fuse (Paladin) London.

Ratovisky, D. (1984) 'Margaret', in Peace News, no. 2220, 11 May,
p. 12.

Reclaim the Streets, online at [accessed 10 August 2004].

Rhys, G. (19880) 'Class War's rough guide to the Left', in Class
War: Heavy Stuff, no. 2.

Rochdale DAM (1985) 'DAM NUM Congress', in Freedom, vol. 46,
no. 2, February, p. 4

Rocker, R. (1991e) Anarcho-Syndicalism (Phoenix) London.

Rooum, D. (1984) 'Wildcat', in Freedom, vol. 45, no. 11, November,
p. 8.

_____ (2001) What Is Anarchism? An Introduction (Freedom)
London.

Samuel, R. (1986) 'Introduction', in R. Samuel, B. Bloomfield & G.
Boanas (eds.) The Enemy Within: Pit Villages and the Miners'
Strike of 1984-5 (Routledge and Kegan Paul) London, pp. 1-40.

Scammell, M. (1986) The EnemyWithin: Government and the 1984/
85 Miners' Strike, Strathclyde Papers on Politics, no. 45
(Department of Politics) University of Strathclyde.

Sheehan, S. (2003) Anarchism (Reaktion) London.

Short, G. (1984) 'Total bollocks', in Freedom, vol. 45, no. 8, August.

Solidarity Federation (2001) 'A history of anarcho-syndicalism: Unit
5 - Revolutionary syndicalism in Britain, 1870 - 1910', online at
[accessed 26 May 2004].

Socialisme ou Barbarie (2004) 'The proletariat and organisation',
online at [accessed 9 August 2004], and at

Stead, J. (1987) Never the Same Again: Women and the Miners'
Strike 1984-85 (Women's Press) London.

Stears, M. (1998) 'Guild socialism and ideological diversity of the
British Left, 1914-1926', in Journal of Political Ideology, vol. 3, no.
3.

Stirner, N. (1993) The Ego and Its Own, trans. S. Byington (Rebel
Press) London.

Stuart, S. (1984) 'From Angel Alley', in Freedom, vol. 45, no. 10,
October, p. 2.

_____ (1985) 'Anarchy defeat and the miners', in Freedom, vol. 46,
no. 3, March, pp. 6-7.

Sutcliffe, L. & B. Hill (1985) Let Them Eat Coal: The Political Use
of Social Security During the Miners' Strike (Canary Press) London.

Tarquin (1984) 'Miners v. Police', in Green Anarchist, no. 3,
November-December, p. 3.

Taylor, A. (1984) The Politics of the Yorkshire Miners (Croom
Helm) London.

Tucker, B. (2004) 'Capital, profits and interest', available online at
[accessed 25 May 2004].

Urban 75, online at [accessed 10 August 2004].

United Reform Committee (1994e) [1912] The Miners' Next Step
(Germinal and Phoenix Press) London.

White, J. (1990) 'Syndicalism in a mature industrial setting: The
case of Britain', in van der Linder & Thorpe (1990) (eds.)
Revolutionary Syndicalism: An International Perspective (Scolar)
Aldershot.

Wildcat (1991) Outside and Against the Unions: A Communist
Response to Dave Douglass' Text 'Refracted Perspective' (Wildcat)
London.

Winterton, J. & R. Winterton (1989) Coal Crisis and Conflict: The
1984-5 Miners' Strike in Yorkshire (Manchester University Press)
Manchester.

Witheford, N. (1994) 'Autonomist Marxism and the information
society', in Capital & Class, no. 52.

Wolff, J. (1976) In Defense of Anarchism (Harper Torchbooks)
London.

Woodcock, G. (1975) Anarchism (Penguin) Harmondsworth.

Zizek, S. (2000) 'Why we all love to hate Haider', in New Left
Review, no. 2, March/April, pp. 37-46.

Benjamin Franks is a lecturer in Social & Political Philosophy at the
University of Glasgow's Crichton campus in Dumfries. His book
Rebel Alliances: The Means and Ends of British Anarchisms is due
to be published by AK Press and Dark Star at the end of this year.
_______________________________________________
A-infos-en mailing list
A-infos-en@ainfos.ca
http://ainfos.ca/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/a-infos-en


A-Infos Information Center